THE IMAGE SEEN HERE SUMS UP WHAT'S BEEN GOING ON BEHIND THE SCENES IN ROCKWOOD: A VENDOR IN DEBT, WITH WARRANTS FOR HER ARREST. A ROCKWOOD DEPARTMENT HEAD, WHO EITHER MISSED IT OR IGNORED IT. AND, A BOARD OF EDUCATION THAT APPROVED ALL OF IT.

The department head is Dr. Terry Harris, Rockwood's Executive Director of Student Services.  

The vendor is "Shante Duncan dba Sisters Helping Each Other Reach A Higher Height" (SHERAH). 

------------------------

Shante Duncan is the owner of SHERAH. She was behind on bills, and became a Rockwood vendor under the district's Student Services department. 

Records show, it was a backdoor to easy money from taxpayers:

No competition.

An almost certain approval.

THE RECORDS 

What's written here is pieced together from court records, Rockwood records, and records from state agencies.

Rockwood's Board of Education approved hiring Shante Duncan to work with girls of color in Rockwood's high schools. According to the SHERAH website, Duncan empowers them with safe spaces, personal development and entrepreneurship. 

The total cost was $120,350.00 across 7 contracts, since 2016.

RECORDS SHOW

While Shante Duncan was contracted to empower Rockwood's students of color, in her own life: she was saddled with thousands in unpaid debts, she failed to turn in required government paperwork, and she also failed to show up to court for multiple traffic offenses, which led to warrants for her arrest. (see screenshots below)

It appears no one questioned whether she was the best person for the job.

THE DECISION TO INCORPORATE

SHERAH, Duncan's nonprofit, wasn't officially formed yet when her bills started piling up.

WAGES GARNISHED

In 2012, a judge filed the first of 5 garnishment orders against Duncan, for a used car dealer who was seeking payment. The orders were issued again in 2013 and 2014.

In 2015, another judge filed a garnishment order against Duncan for a second used car dealer. 

In between these two court cases, Duncan started the process to incorporate SHERAH, in March of 2015.

By the time all her forms were filed with Missouri's Secretary of State, Duncan was $14,917.59 in debt from the garnishments.

We don't know Duncan's reason for incorporating, but, it may have been a way to avoid paying. Creditors generally don't take business assets to cover what people owe personally. They'd likely have to go back and get another court judgment against the new business.

HARRIS TO THE RESCUE: A CONFLICT OF INTEREST

As Executive Director of Student Services, Harris was allegedly involved in SHERAH since its "inception." He is quoted saying so, on the SHERAH website. 

Note: Quote from SHERAH, Harris image from Rockwood website

Additionally, Harris was on Duncan's board of directors for SHERAH. He quietly joined in August of 2016.

TWO MONTHS later, in October of 2016, Duncan got her first SHERAH contract with Rockwood. 

SHERAH Rockwood contract 1

It doesn't say on the contract that Harris was on SHERAH's board of directors.

The approval happened on October 20th; ironically, the very same day that a judge issued a 5th and final garnishment order against Duncan. 

Total debt at this point: $15,881.78
Rockwood contract:      $17,500.00.

It was pretty easy money to get. 

NO BID--SINGLE SOURCE VENDOR

Harris' department submitted Duncan's contract. A designation on the contract ensured she had no competition for the job: "single source" vendor. No other bids are required for a job that has a "single source" vendor. The designation means the business is the only one that provides that service or meets that particular need.

SHERAH Rockwood contract 1

Note: SHERAH was designated "single source" on all 8 contracts, as were other businesses advertising similar services. If they provide similar services, it's not likely they can all be "single source" vendors.

CONSENT AGENDA ITEM

As a purchase item that is $7,500 or more, the SHERAH contract was lumped in with all the other consent agenda items on the Board of Education's meeting agenda. Those items are nearly always approved all together with one vote, with no discussion or even naming the contracts. The consent agenda item vote is really just a formality. It is assumed that whoever submitted the contract has vetted the vendor and the contract is considered reviewed and recommended, or, good to go.

The SHERAH contract is one of the contracts under Student Services

ANOTHER CONTRACT

In 2017, Terry Harris was still on SHERAH's board of directors. His department again submitted a "single source" vendor contract to Rockwood's BOE. The same process occurred. A contract for $20,000 was approved with all the other consent agenda items.

It continued this way every year, through 7 contracts totaling $120,350, from October 2016 through May of 2022. In October of 2022, Rockwood's BOE rejected SHERAH's 8th contract. More on that a little later.

MORE TROUBLE

Terry Harris left SHERAH's board of directors in 2018, but, he and his Student Services department kept submitting SHERAH's contracts.

As the contracts kept coming for Shante Duncan, so did legal and government actions against both Duncan and SHERAH. The Secretary of State warned Duncan three times to file missing paperwork or face revocation, and the Metropolitan STL Sewer district won a civil court  judgment against Duncan and another individual in 2019. 

With no garnishments "satisfied," court records show Duncan was now in debt for $20,854.25.

And, then warrants started being issued for her arrest.

THE ARREST WARRANTS

In February 2019, during SHERAH's 3rd contract with Rockwood, warrants were filed for Shante Duncan's arrest. The charges: failing to appear in court and failing to pay the fine for expired plates. Additional warrants were issued in 2019 and 2020 for other instances of expired plates, an expired driver's license, speeding, and, operating a vehicle without maintaining financial responsibility (no insurance.)

Link to court records; screenshots are below

HIRED 4 MORE TIMES

Through all this, Duncan kept, allegedly, empowering Rockwood's students. Harris and his administrators kept submitting contracts, and Rockwood's Board of Education kept approving them. The BOE voted to hire Duncan 4 more times after the warrants were issued. The 4th contract was approved in August of 2019, and additional contracts were approved in September of 2020, October of 2021, and an addendum in March of 2022. 

DID THEY KNOW?

We don't know what Rockwood's BOE directors knew about Shante Duncan, or SHERAH, when they voted.

BOE directors don't typically vet vendors or contracts. The people that submit them do. In SHERAH's case, that would be Terry Harris and the administrators he oversees in the Department of Educational Equity and Diversity (DEED). Either they didn't check the records we showed you, or they ignored them. 

It would benefit Terry Harris if no one checked, since he was a department head with Rockwood, and was on the board of directors for a vendor that benefitted by getting contracts that he and his department administrators had submitted.

NOT ALLOWED TO DO BUSINESS

The situation with Shante Duncan's struggles became serious enough, that when Harris submitted the 8th and most recent SHERAH contract September 15th (later rejected by Rockwood's Board of Education), SHERAH wasn't even allowed to do business in the state of Missouri. This was, again, due to missing paperwork with the Secretary of State. 

Note: That contract was submitted directly by Terry Harris, himself. Administrators he oversees submitted the previous contracts. This time, his administrator, Dr. Aisha Grace, was out, facing her own legal troubles. She was charged with a DWI this summer.

QUESTIONS, FINALLY

It wasn't until SHERAH's 8th contract that Rockwood's BOE directors started asking questions; at least publicly. BOE director Izzy Imig announced, during the September 15th meeting, that SHERAH was not allowed to do business in Missouri. 

REMOVED, RESOLVED, RESUBMITTED

That contract was removed from the agenda during that meeting. Duncan later resolved the paperwork issue to get back in good standing, and Terry Harris resubmitted the contract at the October 6th meeting.

It didn't work.

Rockwood's BOE rejected the SHERAH contract by a close vote of 4-3. 

The 3 BOE directors who voted yes (but failed) to spend an additional $28,000 on SHERAH, are Jaime Bayes, Keith Kinder, and, Lynne Midyett. 

They are the same three BOE directors who have been voting yes on every SHERAH contract from 2016-the present.

Rockwood's Board of Education
Kinder, Rhomberg, Imig, Midyett, Bayes, Clark, Miller

At the time of the vote, other BOE directors stated they were voting no because SHERAH's L.O.V.E. project for girls of color doesn't serve all of Rockwood's students.

Note: Diversity, Equity and Inclusion has been a controversial topic in Rockwood. Parents are divided over whether total inclusivity is really happening among Rockwood's programs. 

FLASHBACK TO THE AUDIT OF 2013

The audit in 2013 embarrassed the district. It found issues of conflict of interest and a lack of competitive bidding. Among its recommendations, auditors said the BOE should ensure that purchase procedures are followed. But, are those procedures enough?

Rockwood policy states any purchase over a $1,000 should get 3 bids.
UNLESS the vendor is a "single source" vendor.

ABUSING "SINGLE SOURCE?"

Terry Harris and his administrators designated SHERAH as a "single source" vendor on all 8 of Duncan's contracts, which is supposed to mean hers is the only business that provides student empowerment services for students of color. 

But, Harris and his administrators also designated two other businesses, as "single source" vendors, even though they also advertise empowerment services for middle and high school students of color. Clearly, three companies providing similar services can't all be the only company offering that service.

The other two vendors are Sistakeeper Empowerment Center and Tony Thompson, Inc. 

Additionally, student empowerment is also provided by another Rockwood vendor, Alive & Well.

QUICK CHECK OF OTHER CONTRACTS

A quick check of contracts submitted by Harris and his administrators, since January of 2019, shows the vast majority were "single source" vendors. 

Some appear to legitimately be single sources, such as contracts in the second year of a multi-year deal. 

Others do not. 

Examples: a yoga company and a painted mural company. Harris submitted both of them as "single source" vendors, which would indicate that no one else offers yoga or painted murals.

Of the approximately 50 contracts we saw from Terry Harris and his administrators, only 4 of them got more than one bid.

Parents are starting to wonder if another audit is in order.

TRUST LOST?

With confidence in Terry Harris apparently shaken, in addition to the SHERAH contract, the BOE also rejected two other contracts from Harris at that October 6th meeting. They are the "single source" vendors referenced above: Sistakeeper Empowerment Center and Tony Thompson, Inc.

Again, the vote was close: 4-3. 
Again, the three yes votes were Bayes, Kinder and Midyett. 

Rockwood has paid SHERAH, Sistakeeper and Tony Thompson, as single source vendors, a total of $184,770.00. 

If their last contracts had been approved, the total of all 15 of their contracts would have been $270,870.00.

Terry Harris and his administrators have submitted all of them.
Bayes, Kinder and Midyett have voted yes on all of them.

Note: Bayes missed a vote in 2019 because she wasn't at the meeting.

-----------------------------------------

WHAT ROCKWOOD'S BOE DIRECTORS WOULD HAVE SEEN IF THEY LOOKED

Below are screenshots of the documents relevant to this post.

You can find screenshots of additional documents in our previous posts, where we reported on SHERAH, Harris and the BOE's actions:


All the details are from public information that is easily available about the way Rockwood's BOE has voted, the contracts proposed, Terry Harris, and, about Shante Duncan and SHERAH. 

Click on the images to make them larger.

COURT CASES (only warrants that are active are shown)




Since we first reported on Shante Duncan's connection to a Rockwood administrator, court records show she has paid one fine and made that warrant "withdrawn," set a court date on others by filing continuances (which puts those warrants in a "withdrawn" status as long as she shows up for a hearing November 17th), and, still has one active warrant for expired license plates.


Link: garnishment 2012


Link: garnishment 2015



Link: temporary dissolution by Sec of State



TERRY HARRIS ON SHERAH BOARD OF DIRECTORS:

2016

2017


CONTRACTS

The first SHERAH contract is above in this post; all 8 can be found here.

Terry Harris' yoga contract/"single source" vendor:
Yoga contract

Terry Harris' painted wall murals contract/"single source" vendor: 
Painted wall murals contract

-------------------------------

ASSUMING THEY DIDN'T KNOW, WOULD THIS INFORMATION HAVE CHANGED THEIR VOTES?

This shows all the information that was public/available to the BOE about Shante Duncan and SHERAH AT THE MOMENT they took each vote. 

Everything we wrote above is here, as well as some additional information:

Link: Contract 1 and the vote
CONTRACT 1: 10/20/2016  

CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Harris is on SHERAH's board of directors.

HARRIS says on the SHERAH website he's been involved with SHERAH since its "inception." 

HARRIS' department is submitting this contract.

ORDERED TO PAY DEBT: wages garnished from 2 used car dealers. 

---------------------

CONTRACT 2: 10/12/2017 
Link: Contract 2 and the vote

CONFLICT OF INTEREST: HARRIS still on SHERAH bd of directors. 

HARRIS' department is again submitting this contract.

STILL OWES: Garnishment orders still stand against Shante Duncan.

SECRETARY OF STATE WARNING
SOS warned that SHERAH could be shut down if missing paperwork wasn't filed.

--------------------

Link: Contract 3 and the vote
CONTRACT 3: 9/27/2018 

SECRETARY OF STATE: 
Terry Harris was removed from SHERAH's board of directors

HARRIS' department is submitting this contract.

STILL OWES DEBT; Garnishments not "satisfied."

IRS: Temporarily revoked charitable/nonprofit status

---------------------

CONTRACT 4: 9/5/2019 
ARREST WARRANTS
2 warrants have now been issued for Shante Duncan's arrest. 

Additional info/not above:
Note: One warrant was recently paid October 4th, 2022 after 3 years and just in time to be put back on the agenda October 6th, but, that would not be known at the time of this voting.

NEW COURT JUDGMENT 
Shante Duncan owes more money.

HARRIS previously connected to SHERAH.

HARRIS' department is submitting this contract.

---------------------
Link: Contract 5 and the vote

CONTRACT 5: 9/3/2020  

ANOTHER ARREST WARRANT
1/16/2020  Duncan had a 3rd warrant also active for: 
                  failure to appear/speeding
                  failure to appear/expired plates a third time 
                  failure to appear/expired driver's license
                  failure to appear/operating a vehicle without 
                                  financial responsibility

STILL OWES: debts not "satisfied."

SEC OF STATE
Another warning about missing paperwork.

HARRIS previously connected to SHERAH.

HARRIS' department is submitting this contract.

--------------------
Link: Contract 6 and the vote

CONTRACT 6: 10/7/2021 

WARRANTS STILL ACTIVE 
For failing to appear in court/pay for overdue traffic fines.

CIVIL JUDGMENT not "satisfied."

GARNISHMENTS not "satisfied."

HARRIS previously connected to SHERAH.

HARRIS' department is submitting this contract.

SHERAH has been in and out of good standing with Missouri's 
Secretary of State and the IRS.

-----------------------

CONTRACT 7: addendum 3/17/2022   
Link: Contract 7 and the vote;
non-related item is excluded

WARRANTS STILL ACTIVE 
For failing to appear in court/pay for overdue traffic fines.

GARNISHMENTS not "satisfied."

CIVIL JUDGMENT not "satisfied."

HARRIS previously connected to SHERAH

HARRIS' department is submitting this contract.

SHERAH has been in and out of good standing with Missouri's 
Secretary of State and the IRS.


------------------------

CONTRACT 8: 10/6/2022
Link: Contract 8 and
one of the votes

SECRETARY OF STATE
SHERAH was not allowed to do business since June, 2022; issue resolved.

WARRANTS STILL ACTIVE
One of them was paid 2 days prior.

GARNISHMENTS not "satisfied."

CIVIL JUDGMENT not "satisfied."

HARRIS previously connected to SHERAH.

HARRIS is resubmitting this contract, himself, after first 
submitting it in September, while SHERAH was not able to
operate as a business.
The other 2 votes 10/6/2022

SHERAH has been in and out of good standing with Missouri's 
Secretary of State and the IRS.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------